Is Hip Replacement Considered High-Risk Surgery? | Complications & Risks of Joint Arthroplasty

Welcome to a crucial discussion on hip replacement surgery, a transformative procedure that can dramatically improve the quality of life for those suffering from severe hip pain.

While hip replacement is generally safe and effective, it’s important to recognize it as a major surgical intervention. As with any substantial medical procedure, it comes with its own inherent set of complications and risks.

In this article, we will delve into the factors that categorize hip replacement surgery as high-risk and examine the potential challenges and considerations of joint arthroplasty, helping you make an informed decision for your health.

Understanding Hip Replacement as a Surgical Option

Hip replacement surgery, technically known as total hip joint arthroplasty, is an operation that’s not typically classified as high-risk.

It is a common procedure that involves removing the damaged hip joint and replacing it with a prosthetic implant. This type of joint replacement surgery has revolutionized the treatment of severe hip pain and disability due to arthritis or injuries.

It’s crucial for patients considering hip replacement to understand that, like any surgical procedure, it does carry a degree of risk; however, those risks are generally manageable, especially when the surgery is performed by a skilled orthopedic surgeon. 

When discussing hip replacements, it’s essential to consider both the benefits and potential complications. A well-planned hip replacement can offer a significant improvement in quality of life, restoring mobility and relieving pain. Yet, it is important to acknowledge that complications can sometimes occur.

Overall, joint replacement surgeries, including hip replacements, are considered safe, and most people experience a smooth recovery and a significant improvement in their daily activities post-surgery.

What Is Hip Replacement Surgery and When Is It Considered?

Hip replacement surgery, often referred to as hip arthroplasty, is a surgical procedure aimed at relieving pain and restoring function in severely diseased hip joints. This form of joint replacement surgery involves the removal of a damaged hip joint, replaced with an artificial joint composed of metal, ceramic, or plastic components.

Typically, this operation is considered for patients who haven’t found pain relief from other treatments and whose daily lives are significantly impacted by the hip pain. When conservative measures such as medication, physical therapy, and lifestyle modifications don’t provide sufficient relief, hip replacement may be the next step.

In my experience, after seeing hundreds, if not thousands, of hip pain patients in my outpatient orthopedic physical therapy clinic over more than four decades, there are many effective options for pain control before resorting to total hip replacement.

All the orthopedic surgeons I work with are very discouraging to potential hip replacement patients until the imaging shows there is no cartilage left in the hip, and it is bone-on-bone.

It is essential to understand that while any major surgical procedure poses risks, hip replacement surgery isn’t usually regarded as high-risk when performed by skilled orthopedic professionals. It has become a routine procedure with a high success rate, especially for those suffering from hip joint issues like osteoarthritis or rheumatoid arthritis. With advances in medical technology, hip replacements now offer enhanced durability and a smoother recovery process.

However, all surgeons and all hospitals are not created equal.
Read my article:
How To Choose A Surgeon For Hip Replacement: A PT’s View

All surgical approaches are also not equal either, in my opinion.
If I were contemplating a hip replacement and the options of posterior, lateral, and anterior approaches were available, I would always choose the anterior approach for myself.
I have seen much quicker initial recovery time with a much smaller surgical incision, less pain, fewer range of motion restrictions, and a lower chance of hip dislocation.
Read my article:
Total Hip Precautions: Anterior, Posterior & Lateral Approaches

THR Scar Anterior cropped watermarked
Very small surgical incision with an
Anterior Approach Total Hip Replacement
THR Scar Posterior cropped Watermarked
Much larger surgical incision with a
Posterior Approach Total Hip Replacement

Evaluating the Risks: Is Hip Replacement High-Risk Surgery?

When considering whether a hip replacement is high-risk surgery, it’s important to acknowledge that all surgical procedures carry some level of risk. However, the consensus among medical professionals is that hip replacement surgery isn’t considered a risky procedure, especially when compared to other complex surgeries.

As an orthopedic physical therapist with extensive experience, I’ve witnessed many patients successfully undergo hip replacement, which isn’t generally held as a high-risk operation. Nevertheless, there are potential risk factors involved with joint arthroplasty; these typically include surgical complications, anesthesia reactions, and postoperative issues such as infections or blood clots.
Read my article:
How Long to Wear Compression Socks After Surgery: Post-Surgery TED Hose Guide

While blood clots and hip infections can both be life-threatening, in my experience, blood clot issues, contained, are resolved quickly and without surgical interventions unless the patient requires a filter to be placed in the leg vein to prevent fragments from reaching the heart, lungs, or brain.

Infections, on the other hand, usually require drip IV antibiotics for several days to weeks, and most infected hips I’ve encountered required opening the surgical site and placing an antibiotic spacer in the hip joint until the infection is resolved, then returning to the operating room for total hip revision.

While on drip antibiotics, which require the patient to be tethered to an IV pole, the spacer in the hip joint cannot bear weight, so the patient is non-weight-bearing on the hip until the revision can be done. In my experience, this takes several weeks.

So being tethered to an IV pole in one hand and being non-weight bearing on the infected hip makes it almost impossible for the patient to walk, so most of my patients are in a wheelchair most of the day.

That being said, in my opinion, hip infection after total hip replacement is way more devastating to my patient than a blood clot development, as long as the blood clot is contained and not allowed to fragment

In my opinion, choosing the surgeon and hospital with the lowest infection rate is the best pre-surgery decision a total hip replacement candidate can make.

An extensive pre-operative assessment to identify any heightened risks, which are unique to each patient, is essential to deciding if someone is a good candidate for total hip replacement.

An extensive pre-operative assessment to identify any heightened risks, which are unique to each patient, is essential to deciding if someone is a good candidate for total hip replacement.

Identifying the High Risks and Complications of Hip Joint Arthroplasty

When considering total hip arthroplasty, often referred to as a hip replacement, it’s crucial to understand the associated risks and possible complications. Though this surgery can markedly improve quality of life for those with deteriorating hip joint function, it is not without increased risk.

Despite being a routine procedure for joint replacement, complications can occur, such as infection, blood clots, and prosthetic dislocation or wear, leading to the need for a revision. These risks are amplified in patients with underlying health conditions or those leading a sedentary lifestyle.

Total hip prostheses are not bulletproof. They are susceptible to damage based on lifestyle, which can shorten the prosthesis’s life span, requiring a revision.

The worst abuse I ever saw was a 20-year-old rodeo rider who had destroyed two previous hip prostheses and was my patient just after his third total hip replacement. His doctors informed him that not enough bone remained for a fourth replacement, but he told me he intended to get back to rodeo bronc riding as soon as possible.

Thorough preoperative evaluations aim to mitigate said risks, ensuring the surgery aligns with the patient’s overall health status. Nevertheless, with advanced surgical techniques and postoperative care, the success rate of hip arthroplasty has significantly improved, reducing the incidence of complications.

Still, it’s essential to have an open discussion with your healthcare provider about the risks and benefits of hip replacement to make an informed decision tailored to your individual health needs.

Preoperative Considerations for Hip Replacement

As you contemplate the prospect of a hip replacement, understanding the preoperative considerations is crucial to your surgical journey’s success.

Determining the necessity for a hip replacement is often the culmination of exploring less invasive treatments. When pain and immobility become resistant to conservative management, hip replacement procedures offer a reconstructive solution.

Preoperative evaluation includes assessing the extent of hip joint damage and discussing your medical history to tailor the approach to your needs. It’s essential to ensure that factors such as your overall health, activity level, and bone quality are conducive to a good surgical outcome. 

Diligent planning, including discussing potential risks and preparing for postoperative rehabilitation, can enhance the safety profile of hip replacement surgery. Despite the procedure’s high success rate, it’s important to acknowledge that every surgical intervention, including hip replacements, carries inherent risks.

Nevertheless, the comprehensive preparation can help mitigate these concerns, with the aim of returning you to an active lifestyle. The goal of each hip replacement is to alleviate pain and restore function, enabling patients to enjoy daily activities with greater ease and less discomfort.

How to Prepare for Hip Replacement Surgery

Preparing for hip replacement surgery involves a series of steps to ensure a successful outcome.

Thorough preparation can notably mitigate the perceived high risks associated with this surgery. It’s essential to understand what hip replacement entails and when it’s considered the best option.

Prior to the operation, your medical team will review preoperative considerations for hip replacement, which usually include lab tests, medication adjustments, and physical evaluations. To protect yourself from the potential complications of hip surgery, it’s crucial to follow your surgeon’s guidelines.

Maintain a healthy diet, engage in pre-surgery exercises to strengthen muscles around the hip, and plan for post-surgery recovery needs, such as home modifications and assistance.

Properly preparing for your hip replacement can facilitate a smoother recovery and diminish many surgery-related concerns. Remember that while hip replacement surgery risks exist, they’re commonly offset by the procedure’s high success rate and the transformative relief it provides from joint pain and disability. Therefore, it’s important to balance concern with the understanding that hip replacement is a routinely performed arthroplasty that has improved the quality of life for countless individuals.

The Risks Involved in Hip Replacement Procedures

Concerns related to hip replacement surgery risks are natural when one is considering this joint arthroplasty procedure. While hip replacement surgery is a common and generally successful operation, it’s important to understand that no surgical procedure is without risks.

Each year, numerous patients undergo hip replacement to relieve pain, improve mobility, and enhance the quality of their lives. Thankfully, with modern medical advancements, replacement surgery has become quite sophisticated.

However, like any surgery, certain complications can arise, such as infection, blood clots, or prosthesis issues. Significant strides have been made in minimizing surgery risks, but it’s crucial for patients to engage intimately in the preoperative steps to reduce these potential complications.By diligently following your surgeon and physical therapist’s guidance on how to prepare for hip replacement surgery, you can help mitigate the inherent risks of such procedures.

It is also essential to recognize that while the term ‘high-risk’ may seem intimidating, the term is relative, and for many, the benefits of hip replacement significantly outweigh the potential downsides. Careful assessment and optimization of your health can make a marked difference in the outcome of your replacement surgery.

Common Surgery Risks and Specific Concerns for Hip Arthroplasty

Undergoing a hip replacement, or hip arthroplasty, isn’t typically classified as high-risk surgery, but it does carry certain inherent surgery risks similar to other major operations. These complications may include postoperative infections, blood clots, and the possibility of implant failure.

When considering replacement surgery, it’s important to understand that while the technique has been refined over the years, the risks of blood clots remain one of the primary concerns, along with ensuring proper post-surgical care to minimize this and other complications.

Proper preparation can mitigate many risks associated with hip replacement surgery. While the benefits of hip replacement for most patients far outweigh the potential risks, it’s crucial that individuals are well-informed of these before proceeding with their surgery. With advancements in medical practices, the risks during hip joint arthroplasty have significantly decreased, making it a safer and more effective treatment option for chronic hip pain and mobility issues.

Nevertheless, as every surgical procedure involves some level of risk, it’s important that patients engage in a thorough preoperative discussion to express their concerns and understand the steps being taken to ensure their safety during and after their hip replacement surgery.

Intraoperative Concerns: Potential Complications During Hip Surgery

During a total hip replacement, which is a significant but commonly performed joint arthroplasty, there are various intraoperative complications that can arise. It is important for patients to understand that while this surgery is designed to alleviate joint pain and improve mobility, it is not without risk.

Complications during total hip replacement surgery can include issues such as blood loss, inadvertent damage to surrounding tissues, or difficulties with anesthesia.

When considering this procedure, discussing the potential for these complications with your surgeon is a critical part of the preoperative considerations. In the hands of an experienced surgical team, the likelihood of joint complications can be minimized. However, it is imperative to note that even with meticulous surgical techniques, unforeseen circumstances can occur.

Thorough knowledge and preparation can enhance your recovery process post-surgery. Rest assured, with advances in surgical technology and enhanced operating protocols, the risks involved in hip replacement procedures are continually being reduced. Nonetheless, as an informed patient, your awareness of these potential complications during joint surgery will aid in making a balanced decision about your health care.

Blood Clots and Other Intraoperative Risks during Hip Replacement

Undergoing a hip replacement can be a life-transforming procedure for many, potentially alleviating pain and restoring mobility. Nevertheless, like all surgeries, replacement surgery carries certain risks, not the least of which are intraoperative challenges.

Among these, the formation of blood clots is a significant concern. During hip replacement surgery, the body’s response to the surgical intervention could induce the development of blood clots, which can pose severe health risks if they travel to the lungs or brain.A meticulously planned approach to hip replacement involves strategies to mitigate these events. Expert teams constantly monitor for signs of blood clots during and after replacement surgery.
Read my article:
How Long to Wear Compression Socks After Surgery: Post-Surgery TED Hose Guide

In addition to vigilance for blood clots, surgeons are acutely aware of the spectrum of potential intraoperative risks that could complicate the procedure. These risks include, but aren’t limited to, infection, the possibility of damage to surrounding tissues, and complications related to anesthesia. For patients considering hip replacement, understanding the balance between these risks and the benefits of the surgery is a substantial part of the preoperative discussion.

Postoperative Care and Complications after Hip Replacement

After undergoing a hip replacement, postoperative care is crucial to ensure a successful recovery and minimize risks of complications. Although hip replacement surgery is generally considered safe, it’s not without its risks.

Patients are usually keen to understand what postoperative complications may arise following their surgery. Common complications can include infection, which may necessitate prompt treatment and, in some cases, further surgery.

It’s also vital to monitor for signs of blood clots, a risk that specifically increases during the recovery phase of hip arthroplasty.

Pain management is an integral part of postoperative care, aiming to alleviate discomfort while mitigating the risks of opioid dependency.

Ensuring a controlled and guided return to activity is essential to reducing the risk of dislocation of the new hip joint, a complication that would demand immediate medical attention.
Read my article:
Total Hip Precautions: Anterior, Posterior & Lateral Approaches

Adhering to a tailored rehabilitation plan designed by your orthopedic team can significantly diminish these risks and aid in a smoother recovery from hip replacement surgery.

Managing Risks and Ensuring Safe Recovery Following Hip Arthroplasty

As an orthopedic physical therapist with an extensive career spanning four decades, I’ve seen firsthand the importance of managing risks and ensuring a safe recovery following hip arthroplasty.

It’s critical that patients and healthcare providers work in tandem to mitigate potential complications. Rigorous preoperative considerations are paramount in reducing the increased risks associated with hip replacement surgery. Meticulous planning can preemptively address common surgery risks like infections or dislocations.

Additionally, understanding the specifics of your hip replacement procedure can arm you with the knowledge to identify and promptly address symptoms of complications.

During the replacement surgery itself, experienced surgical teams employ advanced techniques to minimize intraoperative concerns, including blood clots, which can occur during any major operation.

Postoperative care is a cornerstone in facilitating a successful recuperation. Adhering to a structured recovery plan can help diminish the risks of complications and contribute to a smoother healing process. Ultimately, while hip arthroplasty can indeed pose risks, effective management strategies can lead to a safe and positive outcome.

Choosing the Right Surgeon for Your Hip Replacement

When considering a hip replacement, choosing the right surgeon is as crucial as the procedure itself. A seasoned surgeon brings a wealth of experience and a track record of successful hip replacements, which can significantly reduce your surgery’s inherent risks.
Read my article:
How To Choose A Surgeon For Hip Replacement: A PT’s View

It’s essential to entrust your care to a surgeon who is not only skilled in performing hip replacements but also has a keen understanding of preoperative and postoperative considerations. This ensures that they are well equipped to manage any complications that might arise during your hip arthroplasty.

By doing thorough research and selecting the right surgeon for your hip replacement, you’re taking a proactive step toward securing a successful surgical outcome. With your chosen surgeon, you can discuss all your concerns, including the common risks associated with hip replacement and how they’ll be mitigated during and after the procedure.

Remember, your partnership with the right surgeon is critical in navigating the journey towards regaining mobility and improving your quality of life post-hip replacement.

Through my years of experience as an orthopedic physical therapist, I’ve observed that being well-informed about the procedure, comprehensively preparing, and engaging with a skilled surgical team are instrumental in ensuring a safe and effective hip replacement. Remember to have open conversations with your healthcare team about the surgery, potential risks, and the strategies in place for managing them, as this will contribute significantly to a positive and transformative recovery.

Read my other articles about Total Hip Replacement

Q: Is hip replacement surgery considered high-risk?
A: Hip replacement, or total hip arthroplasty, is generally not classified as a high-risk surgery. It has become a routine procedure with a high success rate for treating severe hip pain and disability. However, as with any major surgery, there are risks involved, which should be thoroughly discussed with your healthcare provider.

Q: What are the potential complications associated with hip replacement surgery?
A: While generally safe, complications can occur, including infection, blood clots, prosthetic dislocation, or wear that may necessitate a revision surgery. Preoperative evaluations and advancements in surgical techniques aim to minimize these risks, ensuring that the surgery aligns with your overall health status.

Q: How can I mitigate the risks associated with hip replacement surgery?
A: Proper preparation, which includes lab tests, medication adjustments, and physical evaluations, can greatly reduce surgical risks. It’s crucial to follow your surgeon’s guidelines, maintain a healthy diet, engage in pre-surgery exercises, and plan for post-surgery recovery needs to facilitate a smoother recovery and diminish surgery-related concerns.

Q: What should I expect during the recovery phase following hip replacement surgery?
A: Postoperative care is key to a successful recovery. It involves monitoring for signs of complications like infection or blood clots, managing pain effectively to avoid opioid dependency, and a controlled return to activity to prevent dislocation. Adhering to your orthopedic team’s tailored rehabilitation plan can help ensure a smooth recovery.

Q: How do I choose the right surgeon for my hip replacement?
A: Select a surgeon with extensive experience and a positive track record in performing hip replacements. The right surgeon should have a deep understanding of both preoperative and postoperative care to manage any complications that may arise. Discuss all concerns, including mitigating common risks, to ensure a successful surgical outcome.

Dr. Robert Donaldson

Dr. Donaldson is dually licensed; physical therapy in 1975 and doctor of chiropractic in 1995. He held credentials of Orthopedic Clinical Specialist in physical therapy for 20 years, QME in California, and taught at USC. He owns and operates an orthopedic physical therapy practice. See "About Me" page.

Recent Posts